Guiding Question: How has the control of Black women’s reproductive choices been used as a way to limit their freedom and equality in society?
Activity 1: Intersectionality
Before jumping into the content, it’s important to help students understand how, based on our identities, we all navigate the world differently and have unique experiences. Kimberlé Williams Crenshaw, is an American civil rights advocate and scholar of critical race theory. In the early 1990s, it was Crenshaw who coined the term “intersectionality” as a framework to understand how aspects of a person’s identity overlap or intersect, creating unique experiences of discrimination and privilege.
Instruct students to open their notebooks and provide them with a definition of this concept before getting into the video (the video I have used in the past is titled “Intersectionality 101” on YouTube). Tell students to write the names of the three individuals – Jerry, Fatima, Greta – in their notebook and as the video plays, to draw or write about their experiences (students may find it helpful to play the video twice, first to just watch, and the second viewing to record their observations). After the viewings, discuss their responses, clarifying as needed to ensure they can explain what made each of the characters’ experiences so different, even when they shared similar identities.
Activity 2: Source Analysis & Jigsaw
(See Note 6 prior to this activity)
Select passages/excerpts from the book that help students understand Robert’s central argument about regulation of Black women’s reproduction. Find passages/excerpts that allows students to identify evidence to support the following claims:
- Claim #1: Reproductive oppression of Black women has been systemic and deliberate
- Claim #2: Reproductive rights must be understood as a matter of social justice
- Claim #3: Reproductive control is a tool of broader social and political control
Expert Groups: Divide students into expert groups of 3-4 (depending on size of class) and assign each group one of the claims utilizing the “Jigsaw” method. Once students are in their groups, have them read the excerpt together, instructing them to annotate/highlight evidence in the text that supports the claim they’ve been assigned. Have each group also provide reasoning that explains how the evidence they selected connects to their claim. Depending on the length of the excerpt, time might vary but give students 25 minutes to complete this first round. Provide students with a graphic organizer that has space provided to do this work in addition to space needed for the teaching group round. Check-in with each group before the next round to clarify anything as needed.
Teaching Groups: Instruct students that they are now going to move into their “teaching groups" and there needs to be at least 1 representative from each “expert” group in the new teaching groups (try to limit multiple experts within a teaching group to two). Instruct students to take turns sharing their assigned claim, the evidence they selected, and their reasoning. As students are listening to their peers, they should write down the information that supports the other two claims on their graphic organizers based on what they’re hearing.
Whole Group Debrief:
Bring students back together and debrief their discussions, clarifying any lingering questions.
Closure:
Ask students to respond to the following question as an Exit Ticket: Why is it important to understand Black women’s struggles for reproductive freedom by looking at how race, gender, and class are connected?