Richard R. MacMahon, Ph.D.
STUDENT: ROLE:
Information
¥ Information presented was accurate and understandable 3
¥ Information presented was essentially correct 2
¥ Information was lacking in detail and clarity 1
¥ Information was inaccurate and unclear 0
Effectiveness
¥ Statements made were concise and informative 3
¥ Statements made were adequate 2
¥ Statements made were poor 1
¥ Statements made did not address the issue 0
Argument/Testimony
¥ Was relevant and pertinent to the issue 3
¥ Was mostly relevant 2
¥ Was somewhat irrelevant 1
¥ Was irrelevant or missing 0
Conclusions
¥ Were valid, relevant and clearly expressed 3
¥ Were generally valid and fairly clear 2
¥ Were not entirely valid and not entirely clear 1
¥ Were invalid, irrelevant or missing 0
Total
COMMENTS:
